IEPTT
Improving Employee Participation in Twin Transition
Improving Employee Participation in Twin Transition
The machinery sector occupies a strategic place in Europe’s industrial structure. It supplies equipment, components, technical systems and production technologies used across many other sectors, including construction, transport, energy, agriculture, metallurgy, automotive production and environmental technologies. For this reason, the digital and green transformation of the machinery sector has effects that reach far beyond individual companies. It influences wider European value chains, regional labour markets, technological innovation and the ability of industry to meet climate and competitiveness targets.
The sector is also particularly exposed to the pressures of the twin transition. On the one hand, machinery companies are expected to modernise production through automation, robotics, digital production planning, sensor-based monitoring, data analytics, artificial intelligence and predictive maintenance. On the other hand, they must respond to environmental requirements by reducing energy consumption, lowering emissions, improving material efficiency, limiting waste and adapting to circular economy principles. These processes require investment, new skills, new forms of work organisation and stronger cooperation between management and workers. In the machinery sector, these processes are not abstract policy concepts. They are visible in the introduction of automated assembly lines, digital quality-control systems, energy monitoring, smart sensors, new waste-management procedures, and the redesign of production workflows.
However, IEPTT research shows that this transition is uneven. Large and internationally connected companies usually adapt faster because they have better access to finance, technology, management expertise and training systems. Small and medium-sized enterprises often face more serious barriers, including limited resources, lack of qualified staff, fragmented support and uncertainty about which technologies or sustainability measures to prioritise.
This sectoral context is important because the success of the twin transition depends not only on investment in technologies, but also on the capacity of workers, employers and social partners to understand, negotiate and implement change. The machinery sector needs to become more digital, more energy-efficient and more competitive. But also it must also become more participatory.
The IEPTT project gathered evidence from seven national reports: Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Italy, Lithuania, Montenegro, Poland and Ukraine. The research used surveys, expert interviews and focus groups to examine awareness, preparedness, participation, training needs and barriers to inclusive twin transition in the machinery sector.
Across countries, several findings are particularly important. First, awareness of the twin transition is generally low or moderate. Workers often recognise that technological and environmental changes are taking place, but they do not always understand the broader concept of the twin transition, the EU policy framework, or the likely consequences for their jobs. In Poland, average awareness scores were low, around 2.3–2.6 on a five-point scale, indicating a significant education and communication gap. In Ukraine, only 7% of surveyed workers rated their knowledge of the twin transition concept as high, while 43% rated it as low or very low.
Second, workers’ participation in transition decisions remains weak in the countries analysed in the project. In many enterprises, digitalisation and environmental initiatives are planned and implemented by management, technical departments or external consultants, while workers are informed late or only after decisions have already been made. The Action Plan states that all national reports stress the top-down nature of decision-making in most machinery firms, with digital and environmental initiatives usually designed without meaningful consultation. The Polish report shows that 70% of respondents assessed employee influence as weak, while the Ukrainian report reports that 73% of respondents saw employee influence as slight.
Third, the research shows a significant skills mismatch. The machinery workforce needs digital skills, green skills and hybrid competences combining technical, environmental and problem-solving abilities. Yet training systems are often fragmented and access to learning is uneven. The Lithuanian report stresses the need for upskilling and reskilling programmes focused on green technologies, digital skills and automation, implemented in cooperation between educational institutions, trade unions and employers. The Ukrainian report identifies digital skills, hybrid skills and green skills among the most needed training areas. The Action Plan also stresses that trade unions are rarely involved in training design, despite their ability to identify workers’ real learning needs.
Fourth, companies often lack coherent long-term strategies. Transformation is frequently implemented through isolated projects rather than integrated plans linking technology, employment, training, environmental goals and participation. The Lithuanian report notes that some companies do not have a long-term transformation strategy and that changes are often implemented as individual projects without a coherent plan or shared vision. The Czech report similarly identifies fragmentation and insufficient coordination between actors as a key barrier.
Fifth, the transition risks reinforcing inequalities. Vulnerable groups may be excluded from training, new roles and participation channels. Older workers often face difficulties with digital tools; women remain underrepresented in technical and engineering roles; workers with lower qualifications may have fewer opportunities for reskilling; migrants, temporary workers and subcontracted workers may be outside formal representation structures. The Final Report emphasises that twin transition may negatively affect both spatial and social justice unless inclusion is placed at the centre of policy and company practice.
Together, these findings show that the twin transition in the machinery sector is not only a question of technology or regulation. It is a question of participation, institutional capacity and social justice.
Bulgaria
The Bulgarian national report shows a clear gap between awareness and real participation. Survey results indicate that a significant group of workers are aware of the twin transition and recognise the need for training, but structured mechanisms for participation remain weak. The report notes that 41% of participants scored their awareness relatively high, while actual participation received lower scores, with 55% answering at lower or medium levels. It also emphasises that more than 70% of respondents gave high scores to training needs, showing strong demand for retraining programmes.
The Bulgarian findings suggest that employees are not opposed to change. On the contrary, many are willing to participate more actively, but lack institutional channels, feedback mechanisms and internal company forums. The report recommends mandatory employee consultations when new green or digital technologies are introduced, participation manuals and stronger partnerships between trade unions, educational institutions and business.
Czech Republic
The Czech report presents the twin transition as inevitable and potentially beneficial, especially for efficiency, competitiveness, circular economy and technological self-sufficiency. However, it also identifies strong barriers, including lack of finance, shortage of qualified labour, insufficient coordination, slow standardisation and weak market demand for green solutions.
A key finding is the difference in priorities between social groups. Management tends to focus on economic benefits, while employees and trade unions focus on job security and working conditions. The report concludes that the success of the transition depends on intensive cooperation among stakeholders, major investment in education and retraining, and a stable legislative and financial environment.
Italy
The Italian report places particular emphasis on inclusion, trust and co-created transition. It argues that twin transition can be perceived as a technocratic imposition when workers are not involved. It highlights the risk that young skilled workers may disengage from local productive systems if they perceive them as non-inclusive, while contractual precariousness undermines trust and willingness to embrace change.
The Italian report stresses that discussions with employees should not be the final step in a pre-planned project, but the space where transformation itself is shaped. It also highlights the need to involve people with disabilities, young people and women in technical roles, treating inclusion as an indicator of transition quality rather than an additional policy area.
Lithuania
The Lithuanian report shows that the machinery manufacturing sector is already undergoing digitalisation, automation, robotisation and energy-efficiency improvements. However, the pace of change is uneven and depends strongly on company size. Large companies have more resources to adapt, while SMEs often lack financial and human capacity.
The report identifies skills shortage as one of the main problems. It notes that many companies, especially SMEs, lack funds for advanced digital technologies, sustainable production methods and employee training. It also warns that when changes are implemented without employee involvement, they are often perceived as threats to jobs, routine or occupational safety, resulting in resistance and lower motivation.
Montenegro
The Montenegrin report describes Montenegro as a small, open economy with important challenges related to industrial modernisation. Its industrial and mechanical engineering sectors face outdated capacities, limited innovation, low competitiveness and shortage of skilled labour. Modernisation, digitalisation, automation, robotics and Industry 4.0 solutions are identified as important pathways to improved competitiveness.
At the same time, the report stresses the need for investment, workforce development, R&D, stronger institutional frameworks and better links with European supply chains. It also highlights the risk that the twin transition may deepen inequalities unless vulnerable groups are supported and policies are designed inclusively.
Poland
The Polish national report identifies low awareness, partial company preparedness and weak employee influence as key challenges. Based on surveys, expert interviews and focus group research, it shows that awareness of the twin transition is low, with average ratings around 2.3–2.6, while company preparedness is only partial, with average scores around 2.7–3.0.
One of the most important findings is the weakness of employee influence. The report states that 70% of respondents rate employee influence as weak, which correlates with a top-down approach to implementation. It recommends stronger financial incentives, training programmes — especially digital and hybrid — and enhanced employee participation as a condition for a just transition.
Ukraine
The Ukrainian report shows low awareness and limited company readiness, particularly in green transition. Only 7% of respondents rated their knowledge of the twin transition concept as high, while 43% rated it as low or very low. The report also highlights outdated equipment, limited funding, weak trade union engagement, martial-law-related instability and low digital and environmental competences.
Employee influence is very limited: 73% of respondents assessed it as slight, while expert interviews confirmed that strategic decisions are mainly made by top management. However, the report also identifies opportunities, including regional training hubs, pilot projects in technology parks, co-financing programmes, educational campaigns and stronger involvement of NGOs and social partners.
The IEPTT research shows that the twin transition carries important risks if it is implemented without participation, training and social safeguards.
Major risk perceived by the respondents in the sector is job insecurity. Workers may fear that automation will replace them rather than transform their roles. Even when jobs are not eliminated, job content may change significantly, requiring new skills, more monitoring and greater responsibility. Without clear employment pathways, workers may experience uncertainty, stress and resistance.
A second risk is unequal access to training. If training is offered mainly to younger, permanent or already-skilled workers, other groups may be left behind. Older workers, women, subcontracted workers, temporary workers and workers with lower formal education may become more vulnerable to job downgrading or redundancy.
A third risk is work intensification and digital surveillance. Digital tools can improve efficiency, but they can also increase the pace of work, reduce autonomy and enable constant monitoring. Algorithmic performance systems may create stress if workers do not understand how data is collected, assessed and used.
A fourth risk is fragmentation of the workforce. Outsourcing, subcontracting, short-term contracts and project-based employment may increase flexibility for companies, but they can weaken collective representation, reduce access to training and create two-tier workforces.
A fifth risk is environmental compliance without social consideration. Green transition may introduce new reporting tasks, stricter procedures, energy-efficiency targets and waste-management responsibilities. If these are added without training, recognition or consultation, workers may experience environmental transition as an additional burden rather than a shared objective.
A sixth risk is weak legitimacy of transformation. The Final Report stresses that employees often remain passive recipients of information and decisions rather than active participants in planning and implementation. This weakens trust and makes the transition less effective.
For enterprises, these risks are also strategic. Poorly governed transition can lead to resistance, skill shortages, implementation delays, lower morale, reputational problems and compliance failures. Companies that overlook the workforce dimension may invest in technology but fail to achieve sustainable organisational change.